top of page

First-Time Landlord? Here Are Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them

Nov 9

5 min read

0

14


Property Management Cost

For many, investing in a rental property can be quite exciting, but there is also a challenge to first-time landlords. The appealing concept of getting passive income from a rental property quickly overwhelms those not prepared about the realities of managing a property. In fact, over 30% of new landlords report significant issues with managing their properties in the first year. This guide highlights common mistakes new landlords make and offers practical advice on how to avoid them, ensuring your investment becomes a long-term, profitable venture.


Table of Contents

Introduction

Trying to Manage Everything Alone

Opting for Limited Services

Hiring a Real Estate Agent Instead of a Property Manager

Setting the Wrong Rent Price

Not Establishing Clear Tenant Rules

Becoming Too Friendly with Tenants

DIY Maintenance and Repairs

Neglecting Insurance and Legal Coverage

Conclusion


Effective Property Management

Trying to Manage Everything Alone

Many first-time landlords assume they can handle everything themselves—from marketing the property to dealing with maintenance requests. However, property management requires a level of expertise in multiple areas, including:

  • Tenant screening: Ensuring you rent to reliable tenants

  • Legal compliance: Staying up-to-date with landlord-tenant laws

  • Maintenance: Timely repairs and upkeep to maintain tenant satisfaction


Statistics show that 50% of landlords spend more than 10 hours a month on property management tasks. Many landlords are clueless about the legal issues that come with it. Carelessness with such a duty will make you face fines, lawsuits, and unhappy tenants. The way to ensure these are handled correctly is to join a professional property management company. They lighten the burden you have to tolerate as you go about managing your business and enable you to scale your investment.


Opting for Limited Services

When a property management company is selected, tenants often make the error of selecting a low level service-mostly a renting or tenant acquisition service-believing the lower costs will help save money. This often develops into problems that cost even more in time and money to solve. For example, without full-scale management, landlords may be plagued with :

  • Eviction processes

  • Ongoing maintenance requests

  • Rent collection issues


The properties managed with full service solutions have demonstrated a lower incidence of tenant turnover by around 10% compared to the latter. That means they benefit from greater profit longevity. A full-service property management company ensures that every aspect of property management is covered, from tenant acquisition to lease renewals and up to maintenance.


Hiring a Real Estate Agent Instead of a Property Manager

While real estate agents are essential when buying or selling property, they don’t necessarily possess the specialized skills required for managing rental properties. A property management company brings years of expertise in tenant relations, maintenance, and legal compliance.


Real estate agents may be extremely proficient in handling the transactions, but they certainly know little about tenant complaints and laws related to a tenant. According to the National Association of Realtors, almost 25% of the rental property owners reported that bad screening among tenants had caused problems such as missed rent payments or property damage. A property management firm can avoid all these issues and make tenants qualified and trustworthy.


Setting the Wrong Rent Price

Getting the rent price right is one of the trickiest aspects of property management. Overpricing can lead to extended vacancies, while underpricing can result in lost revenue. Studies show that properties that are overpriced have 2x longer vacancy periods compared to those priced accurately.

For instance, a somewhat slightly higher rent might be required to get your property in highly sought-after neighborhoods sold, whereas remote areas would need adjustments. A property management company has access to extensive market data and performs rent analysis to ensure that your property is priced competitively while maximizing return on investment.


Not Establishing Clear Tenant Rules

Many first-time landlords overlook the importance of clearly defined rules and expectations for tenants. This can lead to misunderstandings, disputes, and frustration on both sides. Clear policies on issues such as noise levels, smoking, and parking are essential for maintaining order.

Statistics show that most of the disputes of over 15% are due to misunderstandings between the landlord and the tenant, and most of them are terminated either with an eviction notice or in courts. All these problems can be obviated with proper tenancy agreement and house rules with clear understanding.


Becoming Too Friendly with Tenants

While being respectful and professional with tenants, it's also important to set professional boundaries. Many new landlords end up getting overly friendly, which can be crossing into the lines of accountability. Inability to establish professional distance may lead to:

  • Ineffective rule enforcement

  • Tenant favoritism

  • Difficulties handling late rent payments or disputes


According to property management experts, maintaining a professional approach ensures that both parties know their boundaries and obligations, leading to a better tenant retention rate and smoother operational processes.


DIY Maintenance and Repairs

For new landlords, the DIY repair seems an easy way to save money. However, there is a lack of experience in property maintenance, and such repairs can be inefficient or very costly. According to the National Apartment Association, the tenant turnover rate of inadequately maintained properties increases by 25%.


Most professional property management companies work with known and trusted contractors to ensure their maintenance is of quality and time-saving. Also, through professional services, you save time while ensuring that the real estate will remain in its best condition, hence increasing its value in the long run.


Neglecting Insurance and Legal Coverage

Failing to secure the right insurance for your property can lead to major financial issues down the road. It’s essential to have both landlord insurance and property-specific insurance in place.


Research shows that over 40% of landlords face property damage claims or tenant lawsuits within the first five years of owning rental property. Insurance acts as a safety net, covering things like natural disasters, tenant injuries, or theft. A property management company can guide you on the right coverage needed for your specific situation.


Conclusion

It is not without challenges, but the right approach and support will minimize the risks and increase profitability in managing rental properties. Next Brick offers full-scale property management services to help avoid these common pitfalls for first-time landlords. From tenant screening to maintenance and rent collection, we make sure your rental property becomes a valuable asset and not a headache.

If you are willing to help your rental property become a success then get in touch with Next Brick today. We will be glad to guide you through the intricacies of property management so that you can expand your investment portfolio while we take care of the rest.


bottom of page